Justice Dept. 'Unmasking' Review Finds No Irregularities and Is Given to Durham

October 14, 2020 

WASHINGTON -- For years, President Trump has accused national security officials in the Obama administration of wrongdoing for making routine classified information requests called unmaskings, falsely portraying them as part of a plot to undermine him.

"The big story is the 'unmasking and surveillance' of people that took place during the Obama Administration," he posted on Twitter in 2017.

But John Bash, a U.S. attorney appointed by Attorney General William P. Barr to vet the issue, found no irregularities in those unmasking requests, which revealed that the president's former national security adviser Michael T. Flynn had appeared in intelligence reports, according to two U.S. officials briefed on the matter.

The Justice Department has portrayed Mr. Bash's work as a review, not a criminal investigation. His findings were given to John H. Durham, the U.S. attorney in Connecticut, who is conducting a criminal investigation into the roots of the Russia inquiry, the officials said.

Mr. Bash, who stepped down last week as the U.S. attorney in the Western District of Texas for a job in the private sector, was inclined to recommend changes to the unmasking process, one official said. Mr. Barr replaced him with Gregg Sofer, a veteran of the U.S. attorney's office in the district's Austin division who was most recently a counselor to Mr. Barr.

"Without commenting on any specific investigation, any matters that John Bash was overseeing will be assumed by Gregg Sofer," said Kerri Kupec, a Justice Department spokeswoman. She declined to comment on any aspect of Mr. Bash's work. The Washington Post earlier reported his conclusions.

The revelation about Mr. Bash's findings is a blow to Mr. Trump's push to portray the Russia investigation and related matters as an election issue and the Justice Department's scrutiny of them as certain to reveal a "deep state" plot against him.

Keep up with Election 2020

Mr. Barr has told associates that the Durham investigation is unlikely to yield any revelations that can be shared with the public before the election in November; Mr. Bash's findings seem to have knocked down one of the president's key allegations against his foes.

News that Mr. Bash did not find serious wrongdoing by any Obama-era official infuriated Mr. Trump. "Personally, I think it's ridiculous. It's ridiculous. It's a disgrace," he said in an interview with Newsmax on Wednesday. "They actually said no indictments before the election," he added, in an apparent reference to the larger Durham investigation.

ImageJohn Bash, a U.S. attorney appointed by Mr. Barr, did not find serious wrongdoing by any Obama-era official, infuriating President Trump.
John Bash, a U.S. attorney appointed by Mr. Barr, did not find serious wrongdoing by any Obama-era official, infuriating President Trump.Credit...Mark Lambie/The El Paso Times, via Associated Press

For the past few days, Mr. Trump has publicly excoriated Mr. Barr and accused him of failing to deliver on charges against the president's perceived enemies.

"Unless Bill Barr indicts these people for crimes, the greatest political crime in the history of our country, then we're going to get little satisfaction unless I win," Mr. Trump told Fox Business last week.

He said he had asked the Justice Department to charge former President Barack Obama and former Vice President Joseph R. Biden Jr, Mr. Trump's Democratic opponent in the election next month, extraordinary requests by a sitting president to wield the power of federal law enforcement against political foes. The attorney general said this spring that neither was likely to even be investigated.

The president also said he was determined to find out why Mr. Durham was not ready to release a report. "He's got so much stuff," Mr. Trump said.

National security officials routinely make unmasking requests as they read and try to understand intelligence reports and other classified communications; for privacy reasons, names of Americans in the reports are blacked out, but officials can ask to see them to better understand the documents.

Such requests made by Obama administration officials during the presidential transition revealed conversations involving Mr. Flynn. For the past year, Mr. Trump and his allies have placed increasing pressure on the Justice Department to address those requests.

In May, Republicans released a list of names of Obama administration officials who had inquired in late 2016 and early 2017 about the identity of an American in National Security Agency intelligence reports that turned out to be Mr. Flynn, then Mr. Trump's incoming national security adviser. They included John O. Brennan, the C.I.A. director; Samantha Power, the ambassador to the United Nations; James R. Clapper Jr., the director of national intelligence; James B. Comey, the F.B.I. director; and Douglas E. Lute, the American ambassador to NATO.

But the list did not say what the intelligence reports were about, or whether they included surveillance of foreign officials talking about Mr. Flynn or of intelligence targets talking to him.

After the list was released, the Justice Department said that Mr. Barr had asked Mr. Bash to review whether the requests were irregular or improper, and then give his research to Mr. Durham.

"Unmasking inherently isn't wrong, but certainly the frequency, the motivation and the reasoning behind unmasking can be problematic," Ms. Kupec said in an interview with Sean Hannity of Fox News when she announced Mr. Bash's review.

"When you're looking at unmasking as part of a broader investigation -- like John Durham's investigation -- looking specifically at who was unmasking whom can add a lot to our understanding about motivation and big-picture events," Ms. Kupec said.

This is not the first time that the Justice Department under the Trump administration has pushed politically divisive work to U.S. attorneys far from the main department in Washington.

Former Attorney General Jeff Sessions asked John W. Huber, the United States attorney in Utah, to examine allegations by Mr. Trump and his allies about Hillary Clinton -- work that Mr. Durham also absorbed.

And federal prosecutors outside of Washington are accepting information about potential ties between Democrats and Ukraine from Rudolph W. Giuliani, the president's personal lawyer.

Latest News

October 21, 2020
Trump to hold campaign rally in North Carolina as Biden preps for final debate in Delaware

With the November election less than two weeks away, President Trump is continuing his campaign swing through the pivotal battleground states with a planned rally in North Carolina, where he's currently neck-and-neck with Democratic rival Joe Biden. Trump's rally in Gastonia, N.C., comes just one day before the candidates will face off for the second […]

Read More
October 21, 2020
Why They're Trying To Silence Us
Read More
October 21, 2020
McEnany reacts to being 'censored' on Twitter
Read More
October 21, 2020
Democratic House candidate pushes 'defund the Pentagon' idea to fund social services

Democratic Missouri congressional candidate Cori Bush suggested Tuesday that the federal government should take a cue from the recent movement to defund the police by doing the same to the U.S. Department of Defense. Bush, a progressive candidate who defeated 10-term incumbent Rep. William Lacy Clay, D-Mo., in her party's primary earlier this year, took […]

Read More
October 21, 2020
Republicans thwart Schumer's latest effort to shut down Senate, block consideration of virus relief bill

Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer again temporarily commandeered Senate proceedings on Tuesday, forcing votes to halt consideration of a $500 billion Republican-backed coronavirus stimulus bill and to shut down the Senate until after the election. Schumer, D-N.Y., cited his objections to what he called Republicans' "stunt" on coronavirus stimulus and "illicit process" to confirm Supreme […]

Read More
October 21, 2020
Snowstorm in Minnesota shatters record, causes hundreds of crashes and spinouts

An early-season snowstorm dumped a record-breaking amount of snow across Minnesota on Tuesday, knocking out power to thousands and leading to hundreds of accidents. The National Weather Service (NWS) forecast office for the Twin Cities said that 7.9 inches of snow fell at Minneapolis/St. Paul International Airport, which broke a previous daily record of three […]

Read More