On Facebook, Misinformation Is More Popular Now Than in 2016

October 12, 2020 

During the 2016 presidential election, Russian operatives used Facebook, Instagram, Twitter and other social media platforms to spread disinformation to divide the American electorate. Since then, the social media companies have spent billions of dollars and hired tens of thousands of people to help clean up their act.

But have the platforms really become more sophisticated at handling misinformation?

Not necessarily.

People are engaging more on Facebook today with news outlets that routinely publish misinformation than they did before the 2016 election, according to new research from the German Marshall Fund Digital, the digital arm of the public policy think tank. The organization, which has a data partnership with the start-up NewsGuard and the social media analytics firm NewsWhip, published its findings on Monday.

In total, Facebook likes, comments and shares of articles from news outlets that regularly publish falsehoods and misleading content roughly tripled from the third quarter of 2016 to the third quarter of 2020, the group found.

[embedded content]

About two thirds of those likes and comments were of articles published by 10 outlets, which the researchers categorized as “false content producers” or “manipulators.” Those news outlets included Palmer Report and The Federalist, according to the research.

The group used ratings from NewsGuard, which ranks news sites based on how they uphold nine journalistic principles, to sort them into “false content producers,” which repeatedly publish provably false content; and “manipulators,” which regularly present unsubstantiated claims or that distort information to make an argument.

“We have these sites that masquerade as news outlets online. They’re allowed to,” said Karen Kornbluh, director of GMF Digital. “It’s infecting our discourse and it’s affecting the long-term health of the democracy.”

Facebook did not respond to a request for comment.

Ms. Kornbluh said Facebook users engaged more with articles from all news outlets this year because the coronavirus pandemic forced people to quarantine indoors. But the growth rate of likes, shares and comments of content from manipulators and false content producers exceeded the interactions that people had with what the researchers called “legitimate journalistic outlets,” such as Reuters, Associated Press and Bloomberg.

Ms. Kornbluh said social media firms face a conundrum because their businesses rely on viral content to bring in users, who they can then show ads to. Tamping down on misinformation “just runs against their economic incentives,” she said.

Latest News

October 20, 2020
Trump to speak to 'Fox & Friends,' two weeks from Election Day

President Trump will join "Fox & Friends" for an exclusive interview Tuesday at 8 a.m. ET, two weeks out from Election Day. The president is likely to cover a wide range of issues, from the state of the election race to recent reports about Joe Biden's son Hunter. WATCH THE INTERVIEW LIVE ON FOX NEWS […]

Read More
October 20, 2020
GOP turns back Schumer motion to shut down Senate in protest of Barrett confirmation effort

Republicans on Monday night stalled a move by Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer to close down the Senate until after the presidential election as the body's top Democrat continues to protest the effort to confirm Supreme Court nominee Amy Coney Barrett before the end of the month. The vote on a motion to adjourn, forced […]

Read More
October 20, 2020
Trump continues swing through battleground states with stop in Pennsylvania

With the November election exactly two weeks away, President Trump is continuing his tour of the pivotal battleground states with a campaign stop in Pennsylvania, where he's currently trailing Democratic rival Joe Biden. Trump's rally in Erie, Pa., comes just two days before the candidates will face off for the second and final presidential debate […]

Read More
October 20, 2020
The Virus in Three Charts

Want to get The Morning by email? Here's the sign-up. Good morning. Trump goes after Fauci. Thursday's debate will feature some muting. And we look at the current wave of the virus. Let's check in on the state of the coronavirus this morning, with help from three charts. Here's the first: ImageCredit...By The New York […]

Read More
October 20, 2020
Pandemic protest sees Idaho schoolteachers in sickout: reports

At least 400 teachers in Idaho requested a sick day on Tuesday to protest their school district's response to the coronavirus pandemic, according to multiple reports. The planned sickout, which resulted in classes being canceled, followed a similar action on Monday by more than 600 teachers in the West Ada School District. "Currently, we have […]

Read More
October 20, 2020
A Supreme Court Split on Voting

The Supreme Court issues a ruling with implications for Election Day, while Trump steps up his attacks on Fauci. It's Tuesday, and this is your politics tip sheet. Sign up here to get On Politics in your inbox every weekday. Image Where things stand The Supreme Court's decision yesterday on absentee ballots in Pennsylvania offered […]

Read More
crossmenuchevron-down