Why Are States Imposing Virus Curfews?

November 21, 2020 

Cities, states and counties from Massachusetts to Colorado have imposed curfews on residents and businesses to try to curb the spread of the coronavirus, as caseloads reach new highs around the country.

The curfews, enacted by Republican and Democratic leaders, now affect residents in two of the country's biggest states. In California on Thursday, Gov. Gavin Newsom ordered "a limited stay-at-home order" in dozens of counties, barring "nonessential work and gatherings" from 10 p.m. to 5 a.m. And in New York this month, Gov. Andrew M. Cuomo ordered bars, restaurants and gyms to close by 10 p.m.

Some cities, like Newark, have taken a more targeted approach, setting a curfew for residents in ZIP codes with soaring case numbers, and leaders in Europe have made similar moves, like a 10 p.m. curfew for pubs and restaurants in England.

But the patchwork response, with rules sometimes varying from town to town, also has some residents asking: What effect could a curfew have on a virus that seems to be everywhere, spreading day and night?

Nicholas Gradisar, the mayor of Pueblo, Colo., said his city's curfew aimed to decrease mobility among those with the highest infection rate in the state, ages 20 to 50, who are also most likely to be out late at night. The city had a severe spike in cases after Labor Day and imposed a curfew the night before Halloween to try to prevent a similar increase. It was recently extended to Nov. 27.

"The rules for when bars are open are supposed to be that you can come down with your group and you don't interact with others," Mr. Gradisar said. But people are less likely to do this after a few hours of drinking, he added. "That's how this virus spreads."

Governors have given similar reasons for asking residents to stay home at night except for essential needs like groceries, framing curfew measures as a compromise between a full lockdown and keeping businesses open.

ImageThe city of Miami Beach, Fla. In Florida's most populous county, Miami-Dade, the authorities set a curfew from midnight to 6 a.m.
The city of Miami Beach, Fla. In Florida's most populous county, Miami-Dade, the authorities set a curfew from midnight to 6 a.m.Credit...Saul Martinez for The New York Times

Dan Tierney, the press secretary for Gov. Mike DeWine of Ohio, where a 21-day curfew from 10 p.m. to 5 a.m. was instituted starting Thursday, said the governor had considered closing bars, restaurants and fitness centers altogether. But the economic impact would have been too damaging, Mr. Tierney said.

Instead, he said, the hope is that the curfew, combined with the statewide mask mandate and social distancing, will encourage people to reduce their contact with others.

"We think we can make a dent in these numbers by doing what we're doing," he said.

Gov. Charlie Baker of Massachusetts said at a news conference this month that the state's stay-at-home advisory was meant to "reduce the number of opportunities and activities where people gather in groups and get them home with only members of their household."

In California, counties with severe outbreaks will have a curfew beginning Saturday. Dr. Mark Ghaly, the secretary of California health and human services, said the state's order was meant to "target activities that are particularly high risk," like eating and drinking inside restaurants.

"We've seen in the past that Covid goes from zero to 60 miles per hour very quickly," he said at a news conference on Thursday.

While the authorities hope curfews reduce transmission, their enforcement abilities are limited. Some bar patrons, for instance, may gather in homes after a few hours of drinking -- and at-home gatherings of any kind would be difficult to prevent.

"These are best guidelines, so we're not expecting police to go knocking on people's doors or anything Orwellian like that," said Mr. Tierney, the Ohio press secretary. "We're hopeful that Ohioans will do what they need to do."

And though the curfews are meant to be more economically palatable than full lockdowns, some businesses that depend on late customers expect to take a hit.

"It's going to have an immediate effect on our revenue," said Jeff Castleberry, owner of Caz's Pub in Tulsa, Okla., where the governor recently set a curfew. Mr. Castleberry said that the bar installed a filtration system and has taken fewer customers as a safety precaution, but that losing late business will cut deep.

"We've been trying to operate in the right, and operating that way has cost us about 25 percent of our revenue," he said. With the curfew, he anticipated, "we're going to lose half of that 75 percent."

Mr. Gradisar, the mayor of Pueblo, said there wasn't enough data yet to show whether the curfew has helped. He said that cellphone usage data, analyzed by the Colorado Department of Health, has demonstrated decreased mobility between 10 p.m. and 5 a.m.

"You say, 'Don't have private parties,' 'Don't have Halloween parties,' but that's nearly impossible to enforce," he said. "At least we're breaking up the parties a little earlier."

But like cities around the country, Pueblo has had a significant increase in cases. Given this spike, Mr. Gradisar said he and other local officials were "desperate to try anything at this point."

Health experts said it was not clear how effective curfews could be. Dr. William Schaffner, an infectious disease specialist at Vanderbilt University, said that while curfews might have a "modest impact," they should be "considered as part of a whole series of interventions" that need to be sustained.

"There are no quick fixes here," he said.

Dr. Helen Boucher, an infectious disease specialist at Tufts Medical Center, said that, because mask mandates, curfews and rules against gathering indoors are being put in effect together, it will be difficult to determine which made the biggest difference.

"If we see benefits in a month, was it one of them or was it all of them?" she said. "It's hard to ascertain. This is not a controlled trial. This is real life."

Dr. Gregg Gonsalves, an assistant professor of epidemiology at the Yale School of Public Health, called curfews a "crude, inelegant instrument" being used to address a problem without a simple answer.


The police in Newark speaking to restaurant employees about the city's curfew and dining regulations earlier this month.Credit...Seth Wenig/Associated Press

"In many places, it's small gatherings at home," he said of transmission, describing a scenario with "four of us having dinner, and none of us assumes we have Covid."

Dr. Gonsalves said the curfew measures, combined with other measures, were "a logical approach," borne out by practical experience in the United States and across the world. "We're doing what seems to reduce contacts."

But he said that leaders' efforts were suboptimal if understandable, given their compromised position. People are weary of isolation, and the cost of giving up social ties this holiday season is high. Workers at bars, restaurants, gyms and other businesses need economic support, but Congress has signaled that another stimulus package is unlikely before year's end.

"It's really like putting a Band-Aid on a machete wound," Dr. Gonsalves said. "It's not about Republican or Democratic governors. They're all in the same boat. They're not getting support. Faced with the onslaught, mayors and governors would love to do more. But they can't do more."

Latest News

November 25, 2020
Obama to be honored by PEN America

"A Promised Land" by former President Barack Obama is displayed in the window of a New York bookstore. | AP Photo/Mark Lennihan By ASSOCIATED PRESS 11/25/2020 08:52 AM EST Former President Barack Obama, already a million-selling author, is also a prize-winning author. PEN America announced Wednesday that Obama will receive its second annual Voice of […]

Read More
November 25, 2020
Governments boost coronavirus enforcement with required forms for flyers, 'compliance units' for Thanksgiving

States and cities around the country are stepping up enforcement of their coronavirus orders ahead of Thanksgiving, using a variety of means to attempt to get compliance and keep case numbers down as winter and the flu season approaches. The increased enforcement comes as orders have become more strict, limiting the number of people Americans […]

Read More
November 25, 2020
Car crashes into gate outside German Chancellor Angela Merkel's office

A car covered in protest slogans crashed into a gate protecting German Chancellor Angela Merkel's office in Berlin on Wednesday. The crashed Volkswagen station wagon had the words "Stop Globalisation Politics" written in white on its right side and "You damn killers of children and old people" on the other, photos show. It was not […]

Read More
November 25, 2020
'Lizzie Borden' who chopped up her hubby while kids watched issues bizarre defense

AX WIELDING WIFE ? SEE FULL COVERAGE Ax Wielding Wife ? SEE FULL COVERAGE Ax wielding 'Lizzie Borden' who chopped up her husband while her kids watched says she's not guilty because 'she didn't technically cause his death' KNEWZ.COM|Connor Mannion Melanie Sue Snyder was found guilty of murdering her husband Tom Snyder in 2017 An […]

Read More
November 25, 2020
Trump mulling pardon for former national security adviser Michael Flynn

President Trump has told allies he plans to pardon his former national security adviser Lt. Gen. Michael Flynn before leaving office, a source close to the deliberations said. Flynn pleaded guilty in late 2017 to lying to the FBI about the conversations he had with then-Russian Ambassador Sergey Kislyak. He later tried to withdraw that […]

Read More
November 25, 2020
How Californians Are Adapting Thanksgiving

ImageA worker prepared a takeout order on Tuesday at Rudford's Restaurant in San Diego.Credit...Gregory Bull/Associated Press Good morning. Traveling is fraught with danger this Thanksgiving. So is being inside with too many, or vulnerable loved ones. And reckonings over racial inequity this year have prompted reflection on the myth of the first Thanksgiving. In light […]

Read More